Looking for help in your family court proceedings?Bridge The Gap is a free, community-built guide to UK family court.

Back to feed

Domestic abuse allegations in children cases: what the court must do

Bridge The Gap18 November 2026 Updated 18 November 202613 min read

Practice Direction 12J in plain words: how the court handles domestic abuse allegations in child arrangements cases, from the first hearing to fact-finding, interim contact and the 2026 Court of Appeal decisions.

Choose your view

In short: When domestic abuse is raised in a private law children case, the court has a list of duties it must work through. Practice Direction 12J sets them out: find out early whether abuse is an issue, decide whether the disputed facts need their own hearing, protect the child in the meantime, and explain afterwards how the abuse affected the decision. This guide walks through those duties in the order they arise, with the paragraph numbers you can point to in your own case.

What Practice Direction 12J covers

Practice Direction 12J sits alongside Part 12 of the Family Procedure Rules 2010. It applies to any application for a child arrangements order, and to any question about where a child should live or how much time they spend with a parent, where the court considers an order should be made (paragraph 1). Its purpose is to set out what the court must do where it is alleged or admitted, or there is other reason to believe, that a child or a party has experienced domestic abuse, or is at risk of it (paragraph 2).

Domestic abuse here has the meaning in the Domestic Abuse Act 2021: physical or sexual abuse, violent or threatening behaviour, controlling or coercive behaviour, economic abuse, and psychological, emotional or other abuse (paragraph 2A). It does not matter whether the behaviour was a single incident or a course of conduct. Children who see or hear the abuse, or who experience its effects, are victims in their own right (section 3(2) of the 2021 Act).

The duties at the start of a case

Paragraph 5 is the anchor. The court must consider whether domestic abuse is raised as an issue, by either party or by Cafcass, and if it is, the court must:

  • identify the factual and welfare issues involved;
  • consider the nature of every allegation, admission or piece of evidence, and how far it is likely to matter in deciding whether to make a child arrangements order and on what terms;
  • give directions so that the contested factual and welfare issues can be tried as soon as possible and fairly;
  • make sure that where abuse is admitted or proved, any order does not expose the child, or the carer the child lives with, to a risk of further harm;
  • make sure any interim order follows the guidance at paragraphs 25 to 27, and that contact with a parent who has carried out abuse does not expose the child or the other parent to harm.

Paragraph 14 adds the timing point: the court has to identify and record at the earliest opportunity whether abuse is raised as an issue likely to be relevant to a welfare decision. That record matters later, because everything else follows from it.

Working out whether the facts need their own hearing

Paragraph 16 says the court should decide as soon as possible whether a fact-finding hearing is necessary, and gives four reasons one may be needed: to provide a factual basis for a welfare report or for the assessment at paragraphs 36 and 37, to allow an accurate assessment of risk, before any final welfare-based decision on child arrangements, or before considering the need for a domestic abuse intervention.

Paragraph 17 lists what the court weighs up when deciding, including:

  • the views of the parties and of Cafcass;
  • whether there are admissions that give a sufficient factual basis to proceed;
  • where a party has legal aid, whether the evidence used to obtain it gives a sufficient factual basis;
  • any other evidence available that gives a sufficient factual basis;
  • whether the factors at paragraphs 36 and 37 can be assessed without a hearing;
  • the nature of the evidence needed to resolve the disputed allegations;
  • whether the allegations, if proved, would be relevant to the issue before the court;
  • whether a separate hearing is necessary and proportionate overall.

Paragraph 18 requires the court to record why a fact-finding hearing is not needed. That record is worth looking for, because it is the paragraph that shows the allegations have been considered rather than parked.

Paragraphs 19 and 20 cover directions for the hearing, and require a domestic abuse risk assessment to be listed at the same time as the fact-finding hearing. Under the Child Focused Court model, paragraph 19 has been amended so the court must identify the key factual issues in dispute, and how each party's case is to be set out, taking into account anything already in the Child Impact Report. Paragraph 19(c) changed on 5 January 2026. It no longer refers to a Scott Schedule. Instead it asks whether, in addition to other evidence such as witness statements, the key facts in dispute can be set out in a schedule or a table which sets out what the applicant complains of or alleges, including details and examples of specific events and of any pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour, to help the judge consider the alleged abuse holistically rather than focus on individual incidents alone; focuses on the issues to be tried; and sets out what the respondent says in relation to those allegations (Practice Direction Update No. 6 of 2025). A schedule is still used, but the name has gone from the rules.

Not every allegation is tried

Two Court of Appeal decisions are quoted in almost every judgment on this: Re H-N and Others [2022] 1 WLR 2681 and Re K [2022] 1 WLR 3713. Necessary is the key word. A fact-finding hearing is not free-standing litigation; it happens inside proceedings about a child, and it costs time. Re K at paragraph 42 notes that a decision to hold one is a major judicial determination, that the process brings delay and is likely to be adversarial, and that the court should first identify the welfare issues and then ask whether the facts alleged are relevant to them.

Re H-N makes the same point at paragraphs 36 and 58: not every case needs a fact-finding hearing, even where the allegations are very serious, and only the allegations needed to support welfare decisions or a reliable assessment of risk should be listed. Re A [2025] EWHC 1279 (Fam) at paragraph 42 puts it bluntly: a serious allegation may not need to be tried because it will not bear on the welfare outcome, and litigating allegations that have become uncoupled from the child's welfare can work against the child's interests.

So the question is never whether abuse can be proved in the abstract. It is whether findings on a particular incident, course of conduct or pattern of behaviour would change how the court assesses risk and what arrangements it makes.

Being questioned, and questioning, when you have no lawyer

If you represent yourself and the other party has a lawyer, the fact-finding hearing may still go ahead. Rules 3A.13 and Practice Direction 3AB deal with the position where a party in person would cross-examine a protected party, meaning someone who is, or is alleged to be, a victim of abuse by that party. Where the court decides that cross-examination by that party is likely to diminish the quality of the evidence or of the witness, it must consider whether to make a prohibited cross-examination order. If it makes one, the party in person cannot ask the questions, and the court must then consider whether it is necessary in the interests of justice to appoint a qualified legal representative to put them instead.

Paragraph 28 of PD 12J also makes clear that a fact-finding hearing need not be purely adversarial. It can take an investigative or inquisitorial character, provided everyone's interests are protected. Paragraph 28A sets out how that works in the room: each party can be asked to identify the questions they want put to the other party, and to set out or confirm their version of the disputed key facts in sworn evidence, and the judge should be prepared, where necessary and appropriate, to put the questions to the witnesses on the parties' behalf, focusing on the key issues.

Contact while the facts are still in dispute

Paragraph 25 is one of the most important provisions for anyone in this position. Where the court has ordered a fact-finding hearing, or disputed allegations are otherwise undetermined, the court should not make an interim child arrangements order unless it is satisfied that the order is in the child's interests and would not expose the child or the other parent to an unmanageable risk of harm. The paragraph specifically mentions the impact abuse against a parent can have on the emotional wellbeing of the child.

Paragraph 26 says that when deciding any interim question the court takes into account the welfare checklist in section 1(3) of the Children Act 1989, and gives particular consideration to the likely effect on the child, and on the care the child receives from the parent who made the allegation, of making or declining an order.

Paragraph 27 adds what the court must consider about safety: the arrangements needed to minimise risk to the child and to the parent caring for them, whether contact should be supervised or supported and by whom, whether suitable facilities exist, whether indirect contact is in the child's best interests if direct contact is not appropriate, and whether contact will be beneficial for the child.

Paragraphs 27A and 27B cover refuges. Where the court is considering interim contact and there are reasonable grounds to believe the child is living in a refuge, the court must also consider the risks an order would create for the safety of the child and parent living there, and for the safety and security of the refuge, its residents and its staff.

The Child Focused Court: what Re C decided

Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 is the first Court of Appeal decision on the Child Focused Court model, handed down by Sir Stephen Cobb P on 29 September 2026. It matters because it settles that the new process does not water down the older safeguards.

Paragraph 18 of the judgment says it directly: the model does not in any respect undercut or dilute the operation of PD 12J, and judges and magistrates must apply it with the same care and rigour as before. Paragraph 16 explains that PD 12J is expressly brought into the model, with amendments so that the court identifies the key factual issues in dispute using the information already in the Child Impact Report, and so that the report is updated after a fact-finding hearing to reflect the findings made.

The judgment also describes the process as it runs: early gatekeeping, an information gathering stage in which a Child Impact Report is ordered in most cases, a referral to an independent domestic violence adviser or domestic abuse support worker where abuse is an issue, and a Decision Hearing where the judge takes an investigative, problem-solving and trauma-informed approach. It repeats that PD 12J must be read as a whole, that children who see or hear abuse are victims in their own right, and that where abuse is proved but contact is still ordered, the judgment must explain why the order will not expose the child to harm (paragraphs 19 to 21).

In Re C itself the mother's appeal succeeded only on the section 91(14) order made against her, which was set aside; the appeal on contact, parental responsibility, prohibited steps and the non-molestation order was dismissed. That split is worth noting. An appeal can succeed on one narrow procedural point while the arrangements themselves stay exactly as they were.

When the decision not to hold a fact-finding hearing is never revisited

Re D (Change of Circumstances: Domestic Abuse) [2026] EWCA Civ 969 deals with the situation where the decision not to hold a fact-finding hearing is made early and then never looked at again, even though everything later in the case rests on the allegations.

In that case the court at the first hearing decided there need not be a fact-finding hearing. The section 7 report that followed treated the mother's allegations as true and recommended that the child live with her. The final judgment accepted that recommendation without deciding the allegations, so the order rested on a factual basis that neither parent had agreed and the court had never determined. The Court of Appeal allowed the second appeal on all grounds, set the order aside and sent the case back for rehearing, describing the decision as unjust because of procedural irregularity.

Three practical points come out of the end of that judgment. First, where the court has decided there will not be a fact-finding hearing but the section 7 report concludes that the allegations are a material factor in the decision about the child's future, that must be drawn expressly to the court's attention by the Cafcass officer and the parties, and the question of whether to hold a hearing should be reviewed. The risk of some extra delay is less serious than the risk of an order built on facts nobody has decided. Second, judicial continuity matters: the objective is the same judge from the first hearing to the final order, and in that case the final hearing was conducted by the third judge involved. Third, the Practice Pathway does cover this, but the relevant passage sits between stages 2 and 3 where it is easy to miss.

What you can do with this

  • Read the first orders in your case for the words fact-finding and domestic abuse. Paragraph 14 is where the court records whether abuse is an issue, and paragraph 18 is where it records why no fact-finding hearing is needed.
  • If the allegations have been left undecided but a report or recommendation depends on them, say so in writing before the next hearing rather than at the end of the case.
  • If you are being asked to question the other parent yourself, raise rules 3A.13 and PD 3AB, and paragraph 28A of PD 12J, at the hearing where the arrangements for questioning are set.
  • If an interim order is being considered while allegations are undetermined, the test in paragraph 25 is the one to use: the child's interests, and no unmanageable risk of harm to the child or the other parent.
  • Ask for the domestic abuse risk assessment to be listed with the fact-finding hearing, which paragraph 20 requires.
  • If your case is in a Child Focused Court area, ask what is in the Child Impact Report and whether an independent domestic violence adviser referral has been made.

Sources

Walk into court informed, not in the dark.

Explore the full platform, community insights, your journey map, and a 231-term legal glossary.

Please note

Please note: Nothing on this article constitutes legal advice and we are not liable for any reliance on the information provided. Family court rules and procedures can change, and whilst this was correct at the time of writing, circumstances may have changed since publication. For up-to-date guidance, please refer to Gov.uk or consult a qualified legal professional.

Published18 November 2026Last reviewed18 November 2026

Join our newsletter

Community insights and new guides from Bridge The Gap, sent to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Bridge The Gap

Family Court Reality: empowering UK litigants in person with the insight and resources to navigate the justice system with confidence.

For McKenzie Friends

If you'd like to be featured on Bridge The Gap, we'd love to hear from you.

Get In TouchWhy join Bridge The Gap?

Press & Media

Media enquiries and press releases about Bridge The Gap.

Press Enquiry

Key External Resources

Disclosure: Divorce Navigator (divorcenavigator.uk) is a separate service run by the same team as Bridge The Gap. We list it because we believe it is useful, not because we receive a fee.

Intellectual Property: All content on this website, the "Bridge The Gap" name and concept, gap analyses, case journey structures, is the intellectual property of Bridge The Gap and its creator. © 2026 Bridge The Gap. All rights reserved. Unauthorised reproduction, distribution, or commercial use of any content is strictly prohibited without prior written permission.

Bridge The Gap provides observational insights and collective community experiences only. We do not provide legal advice, legal representation, or caseworker services. Always consult a qualified legal professional for your specific circumstances.

Bridge The Gap is run by Libra Consultants, which operates this website.

No endorsement: Inclusion of a McKenzie Friend or business on Bridge The Gap is not an endorsement, recommendation or verification of that person, their services or their qualifications. Nobody is ranked or evaluated here. Explore, ask questions and make your own decisions by dealing directly with each person you choose to contact.

Made with for litigants in person•Privacy Policy••

Website byThe Back Office, Bookkeeping & Web Design

We use essential cookies to stay signed in and remember this choice. With your permission we also use Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity to see which pages help people most. Privacy Policy