Looking for help in your family court proceedings?Bridge The Gap is a free, community-built guide to UK family court.

Back to feed

Why the new schedule of allegations is better at showing coercive control

Bridge The Gap18 November 20268 min read
Why the new schedule of allegations is better at showing coercive control

The old Scott Schedule asked one question: did this happen, on this date? Coercive control rarely works like that. From 5 January 2026 the rules ask for the pattern as well as the incidents, and that change matters if you are preparing the document or answering one.

If you have been directed to set out your allegations before a fact-finding hearing, the document you are being asked for has changed. Not the idea behind it, but what it is meant to show.

Until January 2026 the standard tool was the Scott Schedule: a landscape table with one row for each incident, a date in the second column, and blank space for the other side to answer and the judge to make a finding. It is a good format for a road traffic collision. It is a poor format for a relationship in which nothing dramatic happened on any single day and you were still not free to leave.

From 5 January 2026 the rules take a different view. The change is worth understanding whether you are preparing the schedule or answering one.

What changed on 5 January 2026?

Practice Direction Update No. 6 of 2025 amended Practice Direction 12J. Two things changed.

The term "Scott Schedule" is gone from the rules. Many people still use it, and courts still receive documents with that heading, so do not be thrown if your order uses the old name.

More importantly, paragraph 19(c) now asks the court to consider whether the key facts in dispute can be contained in a schedule or a table which:

  • sets out what the applicant complains of or alleges, including details or examples of specific events and any pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour, so the judge can consider the alleged abuse as a whole rather than incident by incident;
  • focuses on the issues to be tried; and
  • sets out what the respondent says about the allegations.

A schedule or table is still permitted. What changed is what it has to be capable of showing.

Why a list of dated incidents struggles with coercive control

The Court of Appeal made this point in Re H-N and Others (Children) [2021] EWCA Civ 448. The court was concerned that the traditional schedule, built around a handful of dated, isolated incidents, had become a barrier to fairness in cases about coercive and controlling behaviour.

The reason is straightforward once you see it. Coercive control is defined by its cumulative effect. Each individual event is often small: a comment, a check on where you were, a decision about money that was not yours to make, an argument that ended with you apologising. Asked one at a time, each of those has a plausible explanation. Asked together, they describe a system.

A schedule that only asks "did this happen on this date" never puts the system in front of the judge. A person could prove every row and still leave court with nobody understanding what their life was actually like. Worse, a person with a genuine case could be told their schedule was weak, when the schedule was the problem.

What the new wording asks for

The change has three parts, and all three are practical.

The pattern, and the examples. You still need specific events with dates, or as close to dates as you can honestly get. The pattern does not replace them. What is new is a place to say how those events relate to each other.

The issues to be tried. A short list of the questions the court actually has to answer, rather than a narrative that wanders.

The other side's case. Their answer sits against yours, on the same page, on the same theme.

This is not a licence to write in general terms. "He was controlling for years" will not help you. A date, a place, a piece of evidence and a sentence about what changed for you afterwards will.

What the difference looks like on the page

The Practice Direction 12J page sets out the same invented case in both layouts, so you can see the difference rather than read about it. In the old format it is six rows, each a separate dated incident, each answered separately. In the current format it is four themes, each with a short statement of the pattern alleged, the specific events underneath as examples, then the respondent's answer and a line for the finding.

The facts do not change between the two versions. Only the order they are read in changes, and that is the point.

What a pattern can include

Section 1 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 defines domestic abuse as physical or sexual abuse, violent or threatening behaviour, controlling or coercive behaviour, economic abuse, or psychological, emotional or other abuse. It expressly does not matter whether the behaviour is a single incident or a course of conduct.

In plain terms, the material that belongs in a pattern line is the ordinary machinery of control, the things that used to be left out of a schedule because there was no single date to put in the column:

  • deciding what you could spend, or requiring receipts, or keeping the account in one name only;
  • checking your phone, your messages, or your location;
  • telling you which of your family and friends were the problem, until you stopped seeing them;
  • threats about the children, about money, about reporting you to services;
  • making you ask permission for ordinary things;
  • behaviour that left you managing their mood before you could raise anything of your own.

None of those reads like much on its own. Written as a pattern, with examples and dates, it reads like what it was.

How to write the pattern line as evidence rather than argument

A few things make the difference between a line a judge can use and a line that gets skimmed.

Describe the behaviour, then what you did differently. "By the spring I had stopped seeing my sister, because every visit produced an argument that lasted for days" is evidence. "He was controlling" is a conclusion, and conclusions are the judge's job, not yours.

Keep the words ordinary. You do not need legal language to describe your own life, and reaching for it tends to make a true account sound borrowed.

Say who else saw it. A GP note, a health visitor record, an employer, a school, a friend willing to give a statement. One independent record does more for a pattern than ten paragraphs of description.

Put the effect next to the behaviour. If a theme is about arguments in front of the children, say what changed for the children, and who recorded it. A description of a change carries far more weight than the word "distressed".

Do not label the person. The court is deciding what happened and what it means. Give it the material and let it draw the conclusion.

Five mistakes that weaken a schedule

  1. Treating the schedule as the whole case. It sits alongside your witness statement. The statement carries the narrative and the detail, the schedule organises it.
  2. A long list with no grouping. Forty ungrouped rows make it impossible to see a pattern even where one plainly exists.
  3. Evidence references that point nowhere. "Bundle" is not a reference. A paragraph number or an exhibit is.
  4. Answering for the other side, or leaving your own case unanswered. If you are the respondent, silence on a theme can be read as not challenging it.
  5. Ignoring the order. The order decides the format, who prepares the document, the headings or template, any limit on the number of allegations, and the deadline. A well written schedule that ignores the directions reads badly, however good it is.

If you are the one answering it

The new format is harder to answer with a row by row "denied". If you accept that events happened but dispute what they meant, say that plainly and explain the context. If you say a theme is invented, address the examples in it rather than the character of the person making them, because a response that only attacks the other party tends to help their case rather than yours.

What the change does not do

It is worth being clear about the limits, because the change has been reported in a few places as though it settles more than it does.

  • It does not mean every case gets a schedule. The court decides, and it may prefer a narrative statement, or a thematic schedule, depending on what is alleged.
  • It does not guarantee a fact-finding hearing. Since Re H-N and the 2022 guidance for judges on fact-finding hearings, the court looks carefully at whether one is needed at all.
  • It does not lower the standard of proof. Allegations are still decided on the balance of probabilities, meaning more likely than not.
  • It does not mean a pattern will be found because it is alleged. The judge still needs examples, evidence, and a proper answer from the other side.
  • It does not stop a court directing the old layout in a particular case, if the order says so.

What it does do is remove an obstacle. Where the harm was cumulative, the document can now say so, in the court's own format, without you having to bend the facts into a shape they never had.

Where to go next

This article describes the rules as they stand and how they are being applied in practice. It is general information, not legal advice about your own case.

Walk into court informed, not in the dark.

Explore the full platform, community insights, your journey map, and a 231-term legal glossary.

Please note

Please note: Nothing on this article constitutes legal advice and we are not liable for any reliance on the information provided. Family court rules and procedures can change, and whilst this was correct at the time of writing, circumstances may have changed since publication. For up-to-date guidance, please refer to Gov.uk or consult a qualified legal professional.

Published18 November 2026Last reviewed18 November 2026

Join our newsletter

Community insights and new guides from Bridge The Gap, sent to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Bridge The Gap

Family Court Reality: empowering UK litigants in person with the insight and resources to navigate the justice system with confidence.

For McKenzie Friends

If you'd like to be featured on Bridge The Gap, we'd love to hear from you.

Get In TouchWhy join Bridge The Gap?

Press & Media

Media enquiries and press releases about Bridge The Gap.

Press Enquiry

Key External Resources

Disclosure: Divorce Navigator (divorcenavigator.uk) is a separate service run by the same team as Bridge The Gap. We list it because we believe it is useful, not because we receive a fee.

Intellectual Property: All content on this website, the "Bridge The Gap" name and concept, gap analyses, case journey structures, is the intellectual property of Bridge The Gap and its creator. © 2026 Bridge The Gap. All rights reserved. Unauthorised reproduction, distribution, or commercial use of any content is strictly prohibited without prior written permission.

Bridge The Gap provides observational insights and collective community experiences only. We do not provide legal advice, legal representation, or caseworker services. Always consult a qualified legal professional for your specific circumstances.

Bridge The Gap is run by Libra Consultants, which operates this website.

No endorsement: Inclusion of a McKenzie Friend or business on Bridge The Gap is not an endorsement, recommendation or verification of that person, their services or their qualifications. Nobody is ranked or evaluated here. Explore, ask questions and make your own decisions by dealing directly with each person you choose to contact.

Made with for litigants in person•Privacy Policy••

Website byThe Back Office, Bookkeeping & Web Design

We use essential cookies to stay signed in and remember this choice. With your permission we also use Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity to see which pages help people most. Privacy Policy