Looking for help in your family court proceedings?Bridge The Gap is a free, community-built guide to UK family court, written by litigants and McKenzie Friends, for litigants. Real observations, plain English, and people who can help..
A decision not to hold a fact-finding hearing is not the end of the allegations.
2 min readThis content reflects observational insights and lived community experiences. It does not constitute legal advice, always consult a qualified professional for your specific circumstances.
The decision is usually made at an early hearing, and it reads like a conclusion. From that point people assume the allegations have been rejected, and many stop raising them, even where a later report recommends arrangements because of what was alleged.
Paragraph 18 of Practice Direction 12J requires the court to record why a fact-finding hearing is not necessary. That record is the thing to look for, because the allegations do not disappear simply because no hearing was listed. Re D (Change of Circumstances: Domestic Abuse) [2026] EWCA Civ 969 shows what happens when the question is never revisited. At the first hearing the court decided there need not be a fact-finding hearing. The section 7 report that followed treated the mother's allegations as true and recommended that the child live with her. The final judgment accepted that recommendation without deciding the allegations, so the order rested on a factual basis that neither parent had agreed and the court had never determined. The Court of Appeal allowed the second appeal on all grounds, set the order aside and sent the case back for rehearing, describing the decision as unjust because of procedural irregularity. Three points from the end of that judgment are worth carrying into any case. First, where the court has decided there will not be a fact-finding hearing but the section 7 report concludes that the allegations are a material factor in the decision about the child's future, that must be drawn expressly to the court's attention by the Cafcass officer and the parties, and the question of whether to hold a hearing should be reviewed. The risk of some extra delay is less serious than the risk of an order built on facts nobody has decided. Second, judicial continuity matters, and in that case the final hearing was conducted by the third judge involved in the proceedings. Third, the Practice Pathway covers this, but the relevant passage sits between stages 2 and 3 where it is easy to miss. So a decision not to hold a fact-finding hearing is a decision about procedure at that moment. It is not a finding that the abuse did not happen, and it does not settle whether the facts matter.
Download the card and post it on Facebook, LinkedIn, or wherever you're active. Every share helps another litigant find this before their hearing.

Bridge The Gap
Where a section 7 report relies on allegations of abuse, the question of whether to hold a fact-finding hearing should be looked at again.
No fact-finding hearing means the allegations no longer matter.
Reality
They can still matter a great deal. If a report recommends arrangements because of what was alleged, the court should look again at whether the facts need to be decided first.
familycourtbridge.org • #bridgethegap
Navigating court alone?
A McKenzie Friend can help you make sense of this in the context of your own case.
Find your supportWe use essential cookies to stay signed in and remember this choice. With your permission we also use Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity to see which pages help people most. Privacy Policy