This content reflects observational insights and lived community experiences. It does not constitute legal advice — always consult a qualified professional for your specific circumstances.
Litigants often think that once a breach is established, the outcome is automatic, and that having a reasonable explanation won't really count for much against a proven breach.
Breach applications work in two steps. First, the person alleging breach has to prove it happened, and the standard is the criminal one: beyond reasonable doubt. Second, if that's established, the person who breached can raise a reasonable excuse, and there the standard drops to the balance of probabilities, the lower civil standard. A documented, sensible reason for departing from an order, with dates, offers made, and why the other party's position was unworkable, can succeed even where a breach is technically proven.
Download the card and post it on Facebook, LinkedIn, or wherever you're active. Every share helps another litigant find this before their hearing.
The Gap?
"If I breach a court order for a good reason, I'll still get punished for it."
Court Reality
Breach applications work in two steps. First, the person alleging breach has to prove it happened, and the standard is the criminal one: beyond reasonable doubt. Second, if that's established, the person who breached can raise a reasonable excuse, and there the standard drops to the balance of probabilities, the lower civil standard. A documented, sensible reason for departing from an order, with dates, offers made, and why the other party's position was unworkable, can succeed even where a breach is technically proven.
Experienced a gap between what you thought you knew about family court and the reality? Share your own and get credited.
familycourtbridge.org
Navigating court alone?
A McKenzie Friend can help you make sense of this in the context of your own case.
Find your supportWe use essential cookies only to provide you with the best experience on our website. No tracking or analytics cookies are used.