Looking for help in your family court proceedings?Bridge The Gap is a free, community-built guide to UK family court.

Back to feed

When Saying the Right Things Is Not Enough: Domestic Abuse, Coercive Control and Child Arrangements in the Family Court

Bridge The Gap27 September 20264 min read

A Family Court judgment highlights how courts assess coercive control, domestic abuse, behavioural change and child arrangements. Learn why accepting findings and attending programmes may not be enough to demonstrate genuine change.

A recent Family Court judgment is likely to attract attention from family law professionals because it addresses a question that frequently arises in private law children proceedings:

When can a court be satisfied that a parent who has previously been found to have committed domestic abuse has genuinely changed?

The case involved a parent seeking significantly increased time with their children, including a shared care arrangement. The children had a loving relationship with that parent, and it was accepted that the parent cared deeply about them. However, despite those factors, the court declined to make the substantial changes sought. The reason why is important.

The Difference Between Compliance and Change

One of the central themes of the judgment is the distinction between:

  • accepting findings of abuse;
  • attending programmes or courses;
  • learning the language of insight and accountability;
  • genuinely internalising behavioural change.

The court accepted that meaningful steps had been taken since earlier findings of domestic abuse. However, when examining the evidence as a whole, the judge concluded that there remained ongoing attitudes and behaviours that suggested deeper change had not yet occurred.

This serves as a reminder that family courts are concerned not only with what parents say, but with how they behave over time and what impact that behaviour has on children and the other parent.

Looking at the Bigger Picture

The judgment reflects the modern approach to domestic abuse cases, which focuses on patterns of behaviour rather than isolated incidents.

The court examined a range of issues that, on their own, might appear relatively minor. These included disputes about mobile phones, disagreements regarding school matters, attempts to make unilateral decisions affecting the children, and communication between the adults. Viewed collectively, however, the court concluded that these events formed part of a wider pattern that continued to undermine the other parent's ability to parent effectively.

The judgment demonstrates how courts increasingly assess whether controlling or coercive dynamics continue after separation rather than limiting their focus to behaviour that occurred during the relationship.

Domestic Abuse Does Not End at Separation

An important feature of the judgment is its recognition that children can continue to be affected by domestic abuse long after the parents have separated.

The court considered evidence suggesting that the children had become exposed to adult disputes and narratives about the relationship breakdown. Concerns were raised that some of the children's attitudes and behaviours reflected ongoing parental conflict and unresolved adult issues.

The judgment reinforces the principle that children are affected not only by what they witness directly but also by the emotional environment in which they are raised.

The welfare question therefore becomes broader than whether a parent loves a child. The court must also consider the messages children are receiving about relationships, respect, conflict and the role of the other parent.

The Importance of Understanding Domestic Abuse

Another striking aspect of the judgment concerned the evidence of professionals involved in the case.

The court expressed concern that insufficient weight had been given to the long-term impact of domestic abuse when assessing the children's welfare and future arrangements.

This is particularly significant because it reinforces the importance of understanding how coercive and controlling behaviour can continue to affect family dynamics even where physical violence is no longer present.

The judgment highlights that recommendations focusing solely on co-parenting, communication or shared parenting arrangements may be inadequate if they do not fully address the underlying impact of domestic abuse.

Why Shared Care Was Not Ordered

The court accepted that there were benefits to the arrangements being proposed. The children enjoyed spending time with the parent seeking greater involvement and there were genuine advantages identified in the evidence.

However, the court concluded that the risks outweighed those benefits.

The central concern was that increasing the amount of time spent with that parent would create more opportunities for ongoing conflict, undermining behaviour and reinforcement of unhealthy family dynamics.

As a result, the court decided that the children should remain primarily in the care of the other parent, whilst making more modest adjustments to existing arrangements.

Why This Judgment Matters

This case illustrates how family courts are increasingly focusing on the reality of behavioural change rather than appearances.

Parents who have previously been found to have committed domestic abuse may demonstrate genuine progress, and many do. However, where concerns remain about attitudes, insight, accountability and the ongoing impact of behaviour on the other parent or the children, courts will continue to place child welfare above all other considerations.

The wider message is clear.

Successful parenting after separation requires more than compliance with court orders, attendance at programmes or saying the right things. It requires a genuine understanding of how past behaviour affected others and a sustained commitment to avoiding repetition of those patterns in the future.

For separating parents, professionals and those involved in private law children proceedings, this judgment serves as a powerful reminder that meaningful change is measured not by words alone, but by consistent behaviour over time.

Walk into court informed, not in the dark.

Explore the full platform, community insights, your journey map, and a 231-term legal glossary.

Please note

Please note: Nothing on this article constitutes legal advice and we are not liable for any reliance on the information provided. Family court rules and procedures can change, and whilst this was correct at the time of writing, circumstances may have changed since publication. For up-to-date guidance, please refer to Gov.uk or consult a qualified legal professional.

Published27 September 2026Last reviewed5 November 2026

Please note

Please note: Nothing on this website constitutes legal advice and we are not liable for any reliance on the information provided. Family court rules and procedures can change, and whilst this was correct at the time of writing, circumstances may have changed since publication. For up-to-date guidance, please refer to Gov.uk or consult a qualified legal professional.

Join our newsletter

Community insights and new guides from Bridge The Gap, sent to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Bridge The Gap

Family Court Reality: empowering UK litigants in person with the insight and resources to navigate the justice system with confidence.

For McKenzie Friends

If you'd like to be featured on Bridge The Gap, we'd love to hear from you.

Get In TouchWhy join Bridge The Gap?

Press & Media

Media enquiries and press releases about Bridge The Gap.

Press Enquiry

Key External Resources

Disclosure: Divorce Navigator (divorcenavigator.uk) is a separate service run by the same team as Bridge The Gap. We list it because we believe it is useful, not because we receive a fee.

Intellectual Property: All content on this website, the "Bridge The Gap" name and concept, gap analyses, case journey structures, is the intellectual property of Bridge The Gap and its creator. © 2026 Bridge The Gap. All rights reserved. Unauthorised reproduction, distribution, or commercial use of any content is strictly prohibited without prior written permission.

Bridge The Gap provides observational insights and collective community experiences only. We do not provide legal advice, legal representation, or caseworker services. Always consult a qualified legal professional for your specific circumstances.

Bridge The Gap is run by Libra Consultants, which operates this website.

No endorsement: Inclusion of a McKenzie Friend or business on Bridge The Gap is not an endorsement, recommendation or verification of that person, their services or their qualifications. Nobody is ranked or evaluated here. Explore, ask questions and make your own decisions by dealing directly with each person you choose to contact.

Made with for litigants in person•Privacy Policy••

Website byThe Back Office, Bookkeeping & Web Design

We use essential cookies to stay signed in and remember this choice. With your permission we also use Google Analytics to see which pages help people most. Privacy Policy